Close
This site uses cookies

By using this site, you consent to our use of cookies. You can view our terms and conditions for more information.

Return to Session

Public policy recommendation by optimizing an unknown social welfare function

Authors
Prof. Alex Davis
Carnegie Mellon University ~ Engineering and Public Policy
Niles Guo
Carnegie Mellon University, United States of America
Meagan Mauter
Stanford University, United States of America
Abstract

A classical utilitarian perspective on public decision-making is that the public should choose an alternative that maximizes some function over the utilities of individuals, called a social welfare function. If the utility function for each decision-maker is cardinal and comparable with other decision-makers, then there are many valid social welfare functions. We examine the problem of finding a social welfare function that implicitly best fits society’s values, where we assume that a group's decision problem is the same as maximizing an unknown social welfare function implicitly held by the group. While there is a wealth of literature on possible social welfare functional forms based on different assumptions about the preferences of individuals, we propose a new empirical approach that approximates a group's social welfare function based on both individual preferences and group voting behavior. We test the approach's ability to promote compromise on climate-related energy policy among Pittsburgh residents who are plan to vote in the 2020 Democratic Primary. Our three-stage research design first elicits individual preferences, then uses a mean-variance algorithm to approximate a welfare function that fits group voting behavior, then finally makes a recommendation for the group based on that function. In addition to testing whether a group's social welfare function can be learned from individual choices, this study provides a roadmap for solving group recommendation problems more broadly.

Tags

Keywords

social welfare
group decision-making
public choice
decision-making
preference elicitation

Topics

Decision Making
Other
Discussion
New

There is nothing here, yet. Be the first to create a thread